| 13 : BISHOP MCGUINNESS - Girls Tennis (1999-2011) |
| 12 : JOHN MARSHALL - Girls Track (1978-1989) |
| 11 : BISHOP MCGUINNESS - Girls Cross Country (1992-2002) |
| 11 : EL RENO - Wrestling (1996-2006) |
| 11 : PERRY** - Wrestling (Dual) (2009-2019) |
| 11 : PERRY** - Wrestling Dual (2009-2019) |
| 11 : PERRY - Wrestling (1971-1981) |
| 11 : TUTTLE** - Wrestling (2009-2019) |
| 10 : BARTLESVILLE - Boys Swimming (1962-1971) |
| 10 : BISHOP KELLEY - Girls Soccer (1999-2008) |
| 10 : EDMOND NORTH - Boys Golf (2005-2014) |
| 10 : EL RENO - Wrestling (Dual) (1996-2005) |
| 10 : EL RENO - Wrestling Dual (1996-2005) |
| 10 : JENKS - Boys Tennis (1991-2000) |
| 10 : TUTTLE** - Wrestling (Dual) (2010-2019) |
| 10 : TUTTLE** - Wrestling Dual (2010-2019) |
| 9 : JENKS - Boys Swimming (1996-2004) |
| 9 : PLAINVIEW - Girls Cross Country (2006-2014) |
| 9 : TULSA CENTRAL - Boys Cross Country (1937-1945) |
| 8 : BARTLESVILLE - Girls Swimming (1982-1989) |
| 8 : CASCIA HALL - Boys Tennis (2002-2009) |
| 8 : IDABEL - Boys Track (1984-1991) |
| 7 : CARL ALBERT - Cheerleading (1998-2004) |
| 7 : DAVENPORT - Slow Pitch Softball (2000-2006) |
| 7 : JENKS - Boys Cross Country (1988-1994) |
| 7 : MORRISON - Football (1988-1994) |
| 7 : PONCA CITY - Girls Swimming (1957-1963) |
| 7 : TULSA CENTRAL - Boys Cross Country (1948-1954) |
| 6 : ASHER - Baseball (1970-1975) |
| 6 : ASHER - Fall Baseball (1970-1975) |
| 6 : CAMERON - Baseball (1993-1998) |
| 6 : CASCIA HALL - Volleyball (1999-2004) |
| 6 : COLLINSVILLE - Wrestling (2011-2016) |
| 6 : EDMOND - Boys Tennis (1985-1990) |
| 6 : HERITAGE HALL - Boys Tennis (1990-1995) |
| 6 : JENKS - Boys Golf (1999-2004) |
| 6 : JENKS - Boys Track (1999-2004) |
| 6 : JENKS - Football (1996-2001) |
| 6 : NORMAN - Boys Swimming (1975-1980) |
| 6 : PERRY - Wrestling (1961-1966) |
| 6 : SHATTUCK - Football (2003-2008) |
| 6 : TULSA CENTRAL - Boys Swimming (1937-1942) |
| 6 : TULSA CENTRAL - Wrestling (1934-1939) |
| 6 : TUTTLE - Cheerleading (1993-1998) |
| 6 : UNION - Girls Cross Country (1976-1981) |