| 2023 (1) Tuttle over Weatherford 48-21 |
| 2023 (Q) Wagoner over Tuttle 30-0 |
| 2022 (1) Tuttle over Chickasha 41-7 |
| 2022 (Q) Wagoner over Tuttle 13-10 |
| 2021 (1) Tuttle over Newcastle 34-3 |
| 2021 (Q) Tuttle over Wagoner 28-0 |
| 2021 (S) Tuttle over Poteau 28-21 |
| 2021 (C) Clinton over Tuttle 35-0 |
| 2020 (1) Tuttle over Chickasha 42-14 |
| 2020 (2) Tuttle over Newcastle 31-21 |
| 2020 (Q) Wagoner over Tuttle 21-14 |
| 2019 (1) Tuttle over Chickasha 17-7 |
| 2019 (Q) Tuttle over Broken Bow 14-13 |
| 2019 (S) Weatherford over Tuttle 16-7 |
| 2018 (1) Tuttle over Anadarko 31-0 |
| 2018 (Q) Tuttle over Hilldale 42-14 |
| 2018 (S) Tuttle over Poteau 21-11 |
| 2018 (C) Tuttle over Bethany 35-28 |
| 2017 (1) Heritage Hall over Tuttle 55-21 |
| 2016 (1) Tuttle over Cache 38-25 |
| 2016 (Q) Oologah over Tuttle 35-14 |
| 2015 (1) Weatherford over Tuttle 25-21 |
| 2014 (1) Anadarko over Tuttle 42-12 |
| 2013 (1) Tuttle over Bethany 31-13 |
| 2013 (2) Plainview over Tuttle 14-6 |
| 2012 (1) Tuttle over Bristow 34-7 |
| 2012 (2) Kingfisher over Tuttle 35-14 |
| 2011 (1) Madill over Tuttle 35-14 |
| 2010 (1) Tuttle over Madill 26-6 |
| 2010 (2) Kingfisher over Tuttle 14-8 |
| 2009 (1) Tuttle over Bethany 45-7 |
| 2009 (Q) Sequoyah Claremore over Tuttle 40-14 |
| 2008 (1) Tuttle over Pauls Valley 63-0 |
| 2008 (Q) Tuttle over Metro Christian 49-6 |
| 2008 (S) Cascia Hall over Tuttle 13-10 |
| 2007 (1) Tuttle over Purcell 38-28 |
| 2007 (Q) Tuttle over Vinita 36-20 |
| 2007 (S) Clinton over Tuttle 29-0 |
| 2006 (1) Marlow over Tuttle 16-14 |
| 2005 (1) Tuttle over Lone Grove 42-0 |
| 2005 (Q) Tuttle over Berryhill 32-29 |
| 2005 (S) Tuttle over Sequoyah Claremore 28-23 |
| 2005 (C) Tuttle over Cascia Hall 35-14 |
| 2004 (1) Marlow over Tuttle 42-31 |
| 2003 (1) Tuttle over Dickson 16-6 |
| 2003 (Q) Tuttle over Eufaula 27-14 |
| 2003 (S) Sulphur over Tuttle 19-0 |
| 2002 (1) Tuttle over Hugo 34-7 |
| 2002 (Q) Tuttle over Eufaula 39-12 |
| 2002 (S) Seminole over Tuttle 47-27 |
| 2001 (1) Tuttle over Comanche 24-3 |
| 2001 (Q) Tuttle over Kingfisher 37-14 |
| 2001 (S) Tuttle over Sequoyah Claremore 31-0 |
| 2001 (C) Tuttle over Seminole 16-10 |
| 2000 (1) Tuttle over Comanche 21-0 |
| 2000 (Q) Deer Creek over Tuttle 21-10 |
| 1999 (1) Purcell over Tuttle 13-10 |
| 1998 (1) Tuttle over Holdenville 31-20 |
| 1998 (Q) Tuttle over Purcell 44-8 |
| 1998 (S) Spiro over Tuttle 35-21 |
| 1997 (1) Tuttle over Lone Grove 20-17 |
| 1997 (Q) Sulphur over Tuttle 21-20 |
| 1996 (1) Tuttle over Lone Grove 37-13 |
| 1996 (Q) Tuttle over Newcastle 27-17 |
| 1996 (S) Seminole over Tuttle 35-14 |
| 1995 (1) Tuttle over Sulphur 25-6 |
| 1995 (Q) Tuttle over Marlow 14-7 |
| 1995 (S) Vinita over Tuttle 38-22 |
| 1994 (1) Marlow over Tuttle 35-6 |
| 1993 (1) Frederick over Tuttle 27-0 |
| 1992 (1) Marlow over Tuttle 35-15 |
| 1991 (1) Tuttle over Millwood 10-7 |
| 1991 (2) Seminole over Tuttle 24-0 |
| 1988 (1) Guymon over Tuttle 7-6 |
| 1987 (1) Tuttle over Cascia Hall 39-14 |
| 1987 (2) Tuttle over Sulphur 10-7 |
| 1987 (Q) Guymon over Tuttle 21-3 |
| 1982 (1) Anadarko over Tuttle 17-0 |
| 1981 (1) Bristow over Tuttle 15-14 |
| 1979 (1) Tuttle over Heritage Hall 26-6 |
| 1979 (2) Laverne over Tuttle 7-0 |
| 1978 (1) Tuttle over Bethany 28-7 |
| 1978 (2) Tuttle over Newkirk 10-7 |
| 1978 (Q) Watonga over Tuttle 17-10 |
| 1976 (1) Fox over Tuttle 21-7 |
| 1975 (1) Cordell over Tuttle 41-12 |
| 1974 (1) Tuttle over Mangum 49-0 |
| 1974 (Q) Tuttle over Crescent 24-0 |
| 1974 (S) Millwood over Tuttle 7-7 |
| 1973 (1) Tuttle over Hinton 41-8 |
| 1973 (Q) Tuttle over Thomas 26-6 |
| 1973 (S) Crescent over Tuttle 17-13 |
| 1972 (1) Tuttle over Minco 19-0 |
| 1972 (Q) Tuttle over Thomas 13-6 |
| 1972 (S) Texhoma over Tuttle 13-8 |
| 1971 (1) Tuttle over Grandfield 36-8 |
| 1971 (Q) Snyder over Tuttle 14-0 |
| 1967 (1) Tuttle over Ringling 58-26 |
| 1967 (Q) Tuttle over Thomas 44-0 |
| 1967 (S) Tuttle over Okeene 18-13 |
| 1961 (1) Marietta over Tuttle 30-14 |
| 1946 (Q) Tuttle over Mountain View 25-6 |
| 1946 (S) Tuttle over Kiefer 25-18 |
| 1946 (C) Medford over Tuttle 21-0 |