| 2023 (1) Cascia Hall over Stigler 32-21 |
| 2022 (1) Stigler over Holland Hall 34-27 |
| 2022 (Q) Heritage Hall over Stigler 55-23 |
| 2021 (1) Berryhill over Stigler 28-6 |
| 2020 (2) Stigler over Vinita 42-14 |
| 2020 (Q) Stigler over Kingston 49-14 |
| 2020 (S) Holland Hall over Stigler 49-14 |
| 2019 (1) Stigler over Berryhill 55-21 |
| 2019 (Q) Heritage Hall over Stigler 34-9 |
| 2018 (1) Stigler over Locust Grove 33-7 |
| 2018 (Q) Heritage Hall over Stigler 44-21 |
| 2017 (1) Jay over Stigler 35-7 |
| 2016 (1) Stigler over Sequoyah Tahlequah 48-30 |
| 2016 (2) Stigler over Bristow 42-16 |
| 2016 (Q) John Marshall over Stigler 71-44 |
| 2015 (1) Sequoyah Tahlequah over Stigler 26-20 |
| 2013 (1) Lincoln Christian over Stigler 41-21 |
| 2012 (1) Stigler over Jay 55-28 |
| 2012 (2) Stigler over Berryhill 42-21 |
| 2012 (Q) Kingfisher over Stigler 41-12 |
| 2011 (1) Stigler over Checotah 21-16 |
| 2011 (2) Metro Christian over Stigler 29-7 |
| 2010 (1) Beggs over Stigler 13-7 |
| 2009 (1) Stigler over Prague 55-48 |
| 2009 (2) Sperry over Stigler 55-22 |
| 2008 (1) Beggs over Stigler 27-7 |
| 2007 (1) Morris over Stigler 25-20 |
| 2006 (1) Chandler over Stigler 40-0 |
| 2005 (1) Sequoyah Tahlequah over Stigler 49-29 |
| 1992 (1) Seminole over Stigler 21-7 |
| 1990 (1) Jay over Stigler 26-7 |
| 1989 (1) Okemah over Stigler 35-7 |
| 1984 (1) Idabel over Stigler 32-6 |
| 1983 (1) Stigler over Panama 42-7 |
| 1983 (2) Morris over Stigler 21-6 |
| 1982 (1) Stigler over Heavener 25-7 |
| 1982 (2) Morris over Stigler 20-0 |
| 1980 (1) Tishomingo over Stigler 42-0 |
| 1979 (1) Kingston over Stigler 26-21 |
| 1978 (1) Stigler over Kingston 27-0 |
| 1978 (2) Morris over Stigler 43-7 |
| 1977 (1) Roland over Stigler 20-6 |
| 1976 (1) Stigler over Roland 7-6 |
| 1976 (2) Okemah over Stigler 20-8 |
| 1971 (Q) Stigler over Atoka 27-19 |
| 1971 (S) Jenks over Stigler 14-14 |
| 1965 (1) Stigler over Madill 22-6 |
| 1965 (Q) Stigler over Wagoner 36-12 |
| 1965 (S) Stigler over Bixby 14-14 |
| 1965 (C) Wynnewood over Stigler 8-0 |
| 1960 (1) Stigler over Okmulgee Dunbar 20-20 |
| 1960 (Q) Stigler over Heavener 6-6 |
| 1960 (S) Stigler over Hominy 44-30 |
| 1960 (C) Choctaw over Stigler 32-6 |
| 1950 (1) Poteau over Stigler 6-0 |
| 1944 (1) Poteau over Stigler 41-6 |