| 2020 (1) Christian Heritage over Coalgate 49-30 |
| 2018 (1) Coalgate over Lexington 57-31 |
| 2018 (2) Eufaula over Coalgate 30-14 |
| 2017 (1) Washington over Coalgate 49-12 |
| 2016 (1) Hobart over Coalgate 36-30 |
| 2015 (1) Lindsay over Coalgate 40-32 |
| 2014 (1) Lindsay over Coalgate 58-14 |
| 2011 (1) Comanche over Coalgate 49-28 |
| 2010 (1) Coalgate over Frederick 22-21 |
| 2010 (2) Millwood over Coalgate 32-6 |
| 2007 (1) Bethany over Coalgate 48-6 |
| 2005 (1) Keys (Parkhill) over Coalgate 42-19 |
| 2004 (1) Coalgate over Panama 41-27 |
| 2004 (2) Pawnee over Coalgate 42-27 |
| 2003 (1) Coalgate over Pocola 67-0 |
| 2003 (2) Tonkawa over Coalgate 9-6 |
| 2002 (1) Coalgate over Gore 27-14 |
| 2002 (2) Coalgate over Hominy 16-14 |
| 2002 (Q) Ringling over Coalgate 28-14 |
| 2001 (1) Coalgate over Keota 41-14 |
| 2001 (2) Commerce over Coalgate 23-21 |
| 2000 (1) Gore over Coalgate 7-6 |
| 1999 (1) Coalgate over Liberty 22-13 |
| 1999 (2) Commerce over Coalgate 34-32 |
| 1998 (1) Gore over Coalgate 32-14 |
| 1995 (1) Wewoka over Coalgate 40-20 |
| 1994 (1) Prague over Coalgate 28-6 |
| 1987 (1) Davis over Coalgate 38-6 |
| 1986 (1) Coalgate over Jones 28-14 |
| 1986 (2) Plainview over Coalgate 28-18 |
| 1985 (1) Coalgate over Weleetka 50-18 |
| 1985 (2) Coalgate over Quinton 24-8 |
| 1985 (Q) Dewar over Coalgate 20-0 |
| 1984 (1) Maud over Coalgate 23-6 |
| 1981 (1) Weleetka over Coalgate 18-0 |
| 1976 (1) Marietta over Coalgate 28-8 |
| 1972 (1) Coalgate over Heavener 6-0 |
| 1972 (Q) Coalgate over Vian 7-0 |
| 1972 (S) Hominy over Coalgate 20-0 |
| 1971 (1) Vian over Coalgate 46-12 |
| 1969 (1) Talihina over Coalgate 14-10 |
| 1968 (1) Coalgate over Hartshorne 20-7 |
| 1968 (Q) Okmulgee Dunbar over Coalgate 13-12 |
| 1964 (1) Hartshorne over Coalgate 39-0 |
| 1962 (1) Coalgate over Rush Springs 30-8 |
| 1962 (Q) Hennessey over Coalgate 14-6 |
| 1955 (1) Wilburton over Coalgate 19-13 |
| 1946 (1) Okemah over Coalgate 12-6 |