| 2023 (1) Clinton over Bethany 28-25 |
| 2022 (1) Clinton over Bethany 34-27 |
| 2021 (1) Blanchard over Bethany 24-21 |
| 2020 (1) Cushing over Bethany 41-17 |
| 2019 (1) Bethany over Clinton 20-0 |
| 2019 (Q) Wagoner over Bethany 21-14 |
| 2018 (1) Bethany over Weatherford 38-13 |
| 2018 (Q) Bethany over Wagoner 42-35 |
| 2018 (S) Bethany over Clinton 31-30 |
| 2018 (C) Tuttle over Bethany 35-28 |
| 2017 (1) Bethany over Weatherford 35-21 |
| 2017 (Q) Bethany over Hilldale 21-17 |
| 2017 (S) Ada over Bethany 26-22 |
| 2016 (1) Weatherford over Bethany 35-0 |
| 2014 (1) Cushing over Bethany 28-14 |
| 2013 (1) Tuttle over Bethany 31-13 |
| 2011 (1) Bethany over Bristow 59-21 |
| 2011 (2) Bethany over Bridge Creek 42-6 |
| 2011 (Q) Cascia Hall over Bethany 31-7 |
| 2010 (1) Bethany over Bristow 38-21 |
| 2010 (2) Bethany over Plainview 31-21 |
| 2010 (Q) Bethany over Cascia Hall 9-7 |
| 2010 (S) Heritage Hall over Bethany 28-14 |
| 2009 (1) Tuttle over Bethany 45-7 |
| 2008 (1) Blanchard over Bethany 43-21 |
| 2007 (1) Bethany over Coalgate 48-6 |
| 2007 (2) Bethany over Alva 19-18 |
| 2007 (Q) Bethany over Chandler 24-7 |
| 2007 (S) Heritage Hall over Bethany 37-17 |
| 2006 (1) Bethany over Kingston 50-25 |
| 2006 (2) Heritage Hall over Bethany 21-18 |
| 2005 (1) Bethany over Hobart 21-6 |
| 2005 (2) Bethany over Millwood 24-21 |
| 2005 (Q) Bethany over Hartshorne 37-12 |
| 2005 (S) Davis over Bethany 20-14 |
| 2004 (1) Hobart over Bethany 21-0 |
| 2003 (1) Bethany over Comanche 43-8 |
| 2003 (2) Bethany over Perkins-Tryon 24-7 |
| 2003 (Q) Bethany over Sequoyah Tahlequah 30-14 |
| 2003 (S) Bethany over Millwood 28-0 |
| 2003 (C) Bethany over Davis 40-6 |
| 2002 (1) Bethany over Hobart 41-0 |
| 2002 (2) Davis over Bethany 28-21 |
| 2001 (1) Bethany over Lindsay 20-14 |
| 2001 (2) Davis over Bethany 35-7 |
| 1999 (1) Bethany over Madill 42-13 |
| 1999 (2) Fairview over Bethany 31-8 |
| 1998 (1) Tishomingo over Bethany 34-9 |
| 1985 (1) Watonga over Bethany 47-6 |
| 1978 (1) Tuttle over Bethany 28-7 |
| 1975 (1) Davis over Bethany 19-7 |
| 1968 (1) Stroud over Bethany 20-13 |
| 1965 (1) Bethany over Stroud 14-0 |
| 1965 (Q) Wynnewood over Bethany 20-0 |
| 1955 (1) Watonga over Bethany 21-19 |
| 1953 (1) Bethany over Madill 21-14 |
| 1953 (Q) Bethany over Marlow 20-19 |
| 1953 (S) Tonkawa over Bethany 33-19 |